mushy — the u is a smiling upside-down button mushroomTHE MUSHROOM HANDBOOK
Rice & grains

Mushrooms over creamy polenta

Soft polenta makes a simple base for browned mushrooms and a quick balsamic pan glaze. Make the topping while the grains simmer.

Prep 15 minCook 30 minVegetarianServes 2

Original recipe draft · Not kitchen-tested · Metric quantities · Timing is an estimate

Ingredients

Quantities for 2 servings.

Scaling adjusts leading quantities, keeping pack sizes and per-item descriptions. Pan size and cooking time need your judgement. Method quantities refer to the original serving count.

Method

  1. Bring the stock and milk to a gentle simmer in a medium saucepan. Sprinkle in the polenta slowly while whisking to prevent clumps. Turn the heat low and cook according to the packet, stirring often; instant and traditional polenta have very different times.

  2. Clean the mushrooms, slice the Swiss browns and tear the oysters into bite-sized pieces. Heat the olive oil in a broad frying pan over medium-high heat and brown the mushrooms in two batches, about 8 minutes in total.

  3. Return all mushrooms to the frying pan. Lower the heat, add half the butter and the garlic, then stir for 30 seconds. Add balsamic vinegar, maple syrup and 30 ml water, scraping up the browned pan juices.

  4. Simmer the topping gently for 2–3 minutes until the liquid forms a light glaze and the mushrooms are tender. Add a spoonful more water if the pan becomes dry. Season with half the salt and a little pepper.

  5. When the polenta is cooked and no longer gritty, stir in the remaining butter and cheese. Add hot water or milk if needed to reach a soft, spoonable texture. Taste and add the remaining salt only if necessary.

  6. Divide the polenta between warm bowls, spoon over the glazed mushrooms and scatter with parsley. Serve at once because polenta firms as it cools. A side of cooked greens balances the rich base.

Make it work for you

  • Keep polenta heat low and use a long-handled spoon: thick simmering polenta can spit.
  • If using instant polenta, cook the mushrooms first and make the polenta just before serving.

Ingredient swaps

For a vegan variation use unsweetened plant milk, omit butter and replace cheese with 15 g nutritional yeast; check the stock and polenta labels for gluten-free needs.

Know the ingredient. Use mushrooms purchased as food or a known cultivated harvest. A recipe does not establish whether a wild mushroom is edible. Dietary labels depend on the products you use; check stock, sauces, pastry and cheese.